We have all heard the huge uproar of anger that a lot of people have expressed in regards to the trailer released of Resident Evil 5, where it depicts an African Village and a "White Man" is..you guessed it, shooting the "ZOMBIFIED African Man". Now as gamers we don't really think much of this because it is a game centered in Africa and they tried to be realistic with the settings and way of life. Is that wrong? Have some developers crossed the line?
I recently read an article on kezins.com where the author interviewed Ragnhild Mogren, teacher at Stockholm University, about the effect that games like Resident Evil 5 and Grand Theft Auto IV could have on the public -- particularly young minds. But it all boils down to have the developers crossed the line? Personally in my honest opinion I don't think they have. Yes some people see the trailer as "OMG Racist" but how is it? Yes you have a white man shooting a black man, there are plenty of games that have that same scenario and even more movies that have that same concept. But why do some people see this as wrong? Thats simple: KIDS.
Yes we are all sick of people complaining about the youth being exposed to things like drugs, sex and violence (Thank you GTAIV). But now these concerned adults see games such as Resident Evil as a huge influence on kids because of the racism issue. Why should developers try and hide the sad truth about how the people in these types of towns in Africa live? Yes I know that some kids now a days don't sit down a learn about history of not just our country but how people live in other countries. They sit there and watch television which constantly shows tons of negativity with a 1% shower of positivity, so why don't we hear people complaining about what is depicted on the news and television?
It all comes down to the main people in a child's life that can depict to them the difference between right and wrong: their PARENT(s). People say that reading has gone way done since video games have gone to become the main medium of entertainment, this in turn leads to the constant argument that games have a huge influence on a young child and their developing minds. Yet who controls all this? The PARENTS. We have come to a day and age where the old school baby sitter has been replaced with video game consoles and games that these kids definitely shouldn't be getting their hands on.
A few of you might be wondering what the problem is with kids seeing how a culture lives --of course minus the zombie part. Absolutely nothing. I think that the developers where right to stay with the scenery that they chose because it makes a lot more sense to at least stay somewhat true to the essence of the location. But one of the main issues that people are having besides the obvious of "racism", they feel that the developers are portraying the African people in the game as mindless Neanderthals and the White man as All Powerful. Maybe if they give you the option at the beginning of the game to choose who you play as the main character then people wouldn't complain much...wait nevermind..they will complain anyway because that is the nature of people.
Grand Theft Auto IV has also seen the shining light of hatred from many different directions due to its obvious use of: Drugs, Sex and Violence. With a nice "M for Mature" rating on it there are still tons of kids who have gotten a hold of this game but I don't see them running up and down the street acting like their shooting someone. Nor have I heard them talk to a girl called them a "Bitch" or "Slut", or beating up girls for their lunch money. A few women feel that this series is really degrading of women because it promotes prostitution and that we are just a tool to be used. But have these women actually played this game and followed the storyline? Have they seen how the main character, Niko Bellic, acts towards certain women in the gaming? Particularly the lovely Miss Kate, sister of one of your friends in the game, whom he treats with complete respect. This game is all about Moral Choices, it gives you the option to kill a person or spare their life and all of the decisions you make effect you throughout the game including the final mission. So what is bad about that?
Racism and the Degrading of women in video games will always be a topic discussed for a long time to come. But the way someone views these things in not only video games but also movies depends on how the main person in their life teaches them the difference between entertainment and the real world.
Click to read: Why we should care - Racism and Sexism In Games. Part 1 of 2 Why we should care - Racism and Sexism in Games. Part 2 of 2
Comments
Well I am a black male in America and when I first saw the resident evil 5 trailer I didn't think anything racial was being portrayed. I just thought, okay they are moving the setting to a village with what looks to be a lot of black people. They were in Spain last time so this time it's in Africa or Haiti. But then a few days later the reporter N'gai Ncoral(not sure if I spelled it right) did that article about how racist the trailer was and I cringed and I was a bit pissed off. I thought he was taking that game somewhere it didn't need to go, I didn't feel the developers were trying to offend anyone. I
I completely agree with you Aegis.
Hopefully Al Sharpton doesn't get involved, that's the last thing the gaming industry needs.
Some developers are used to crossing the line. Like the makers of Postal and Redneck Rampage and what-not. They think controversy alone will sell, but that's not the case.
Personally, RE5 isn't "racist" at all, at least I don't think. The developers clearly wanted to do something a little different than RE 4 to make it stand out more, and the locale makes much more sense. Not everyone's going to like it, but, really, developers aren't going in with evil on their minds.
Besides, just look at the team developing the new 50 Cent game. Technically, couldn't that be called the same thing that RE 5's doing? One man and his "crew" taking on a different nationality of enemies?
I think it's ironic, considering most kids I know don't have a racist bone in their body. We've finally gotten to the point that MAYBE, just MAYBE, this next generation will put racism to rest for good. And then what do we do? We make a big race deal about nothing, right in front of them, and act like it's for their cause.
Idiots.
Not to mention, I'm SURE RE5 will be rated Mature, so the kids shouldn't even get to play it in the first place.
Like Aegis, when I saw the trailer, I didn't see anything racist about the game. I mean, sure when you stop to think about it yeah, but not until others started saying it was racist. Is RE 5 going to be in Africa or Haiti? (I don't know)Because let me tell you, in Haiti at least, the houses really are like that, the people do live like that too. Hell, Haiti even has the desert and sun part down (they cut down all their trees). I don't see it as racist, I see it as realistic. That makes me even more excited about RE5. It's much funner to play in places you've been to (I know because I've been there a few times- it's the crappy half of the island :P) Hopefully the game will take place there...
Bah, I think the "RE5 is racist" outlook is just something else in this world that pathetic people can take and make a big fuss about. It's funny how people can take such simple or innocent things and make them so horrible.
I agree with Raychul. As usual.
of course theres alot of black people in africa so of course the zombies in africa would be black its like if it was based in japan would be killing alot of jap japs
anyway racism is stupid blacks, whites, japs etc are the same race/species all are homo-sapians just different adaptations for different enviroments
METALGEAR AHHHHH...
Snake?...Snaaaake!!!!!
Would be right to have a lot of zombified japanese in the centre of Africa ? -_-'
I believe too many people are too sensitive about race. If the setting was in Africa then there will be African zombies duh. So if the main character was an African American and killing zombies Africa would that still be considered racist? Just because you're Caucasian killing African zombies that are trying to eat you doesn't make your racist! People need to take a chill pill.
what i find funny is that these games are rated M for a reason and it is no fault of the developer should parents allow there impressionable kids to play them and other facts and statistics state that Overall violence has decreased since video games have come around
ah ya not much more after that
i think we need to make a game where aliens are controling the minds of our media in an attempt to take over the world and we have to extermanate them
Thanks for the link to our article. I like what you have to say about it. I think RE5 could potentially be racist but I haven't played it yet so I can't say for sure. I do think that games have portrayed race and sex in an extremely poor way in the past, but they have improved some.
I also think games that include race and gender issues are always going to be seen different ways by different groups. It all depends on your life experiences and perspective. Gender and ethnicity issues are something I think we still need to keep a close eye on in gaming. While it's still entertainment, the effects of these things in games really have yet to be seen.
Another way to think about this issue:
Wouldn't it be racist if the T-Virus (or Las Plagas) only effected caucasians?
When I look at those screen shots, I don't see black people. I see zombies (or at least, the mindless, blood-lusting homicidal infected) and once you become a zombie, you've pretty much lost all your human rights, regardless of race, creed or color.
The only rights you have at that point is the right to be head shot. And I will gladly help support that right, just hold still a sec...
I really do think that they are going back to the origin of Voodoo with this Resident Evil which is documented as starting in Haiti. Of course, those in the media screaming that it's racist don't care about the background or story development of the video game. They just see it as mindless killing of a white man (who happens to be a deep part of RE's story since the beginning) against hordes and hordes of African people. The whole racism issue as a whole just makes me sick.
On a side note concerning the issue of "Kids" and video games. I'm sick and tired of that issue too. This is a world where you are free to express your ideas and tell a story through a video game if you so choose. People shouldn't whine because their children are being corrupted by "Grand Theft Auto" or any other game that has a Mature rating on the box. It isn't the fault of a game developer that you suck at parenting and can't keep your kid from playing these games that are clearly far too mature (hence the rating) for them. /end rant.
You must be registered and logged in to leave comments.
If you are already have a login with GamePro.com, Gamerhelp.com, Games.net or GameProFamily.com, then use that login!